In a distant place that does not appear on any map, where everything is learned through conversation, there lives a tribe. There is little information about them, but one thing is known for certain: they all sing. They sing all the time — at weddings, at funerals, when it rains and when the rain has been absent for far too long. They sing the same song. And, believe it or not, they are perfectly happy with it.
One day, a visiting anthropologist — a man with a notebook and an immoderate curiosity — asked the elder:
— Tell me, why don’t you invent a new song? Surely you must be tired of the old one by now.
The old man looked at him for a long time, the way one looks at a child who asks why the moon does not fall.
— Why should it be different? — he said. — It is ours. A different one would belong to someone else.
The anthropologist wrote this down in his notebook. Everything said before and after became unnecessary.
There was a time when one melody filled Europe. Not literally one — but, if you will allow the simplification, one for everyone. Gregorian chant. It sounded in cathedrals, in monasteries, in the heads of everyone who had ever attended a service. And this went on not for a year or two, but for a thousand years. A child was born to those sounds, an old man died to them, and it simply did not occur to anyone that things might happen to different music.
Why?
Because music was not entertainment then. It was truth. It had been sanctioned, canonized, incorporated into doctrine. To sing differently was not to be “original”; it was to be wrong. And being wrong about matters of faith was rarely a profitable occupation.
Besides, life was understood as a circle rather than a road. People did not expect tomorrow to be better than yesterday. They knew tomorrow would be the same. And the music heard yesterday would be heard tomorrow as well — and this was not stagnation, but the natural order of things.
But here is the interesting part.
We tend to think of taste as something personal. I like this, you like something else. Taste as a fingerprint. Taste as the right to have an opinion of one’s own.
And yet this is a relatively recent invention.
In a tribe, everyone has the same taste because everyone shares the same world. In the Middle Ages, everyone has the same taste because there is only one truth. And only when the world shattered into a thousand fragments — cities, markets, universities, newspapers, records — did taste shatter along with it.
It turned out that taste is not something a person has inside. It is something they have around them.
It is their tribe, their church, their class, their street, their playlist, eventually. Taste is a way of saying: “I’m one of you.”
And that is why changing it can be so frightening. Because changing the music means changing something about yourself.
And then everything broke.
As is customary in good stories, nobody noticed the exact moment it happened.
First came the cities. People were cut loose from the land; they had money and evenings with nothing in particular to fill them. Then came printing: music learned how to reproduce itself. Then the Reformation: the Church split, and it turned out that even truth could be argued over. Then Romanticism: the artist became a genius, and the new became a virtue.
Then came the phonograph, and people discovered that music could be reproduced by those who did not know how to perform it themselves.
Then radio.
Then the record.
Then the cassette.
Then the internet.
And suddenly thirty years from jazz to rock seemed like a long time. Ten years from rock to punk — already short. And today a style can be born on Monday and be dead by Wednesday, before anyone has had time to remember its name.
There are several ways to create a new style. They are as old as the world, and they work the same way everywhere — in a tribe as well as in a conservatory.
Boredom. The brain likes recognition, but it cannot stand monotony. Someone plays differently for the first time — and others pick it up. That is how fashion is born.
The instrument. A new sound opens a new territory. The electric guitar gave birth to rock, the synthesizer to electronic music, the sampler to hip-hop, Auto-Tune to a new kind of vocal expression. Every instrument is a door that someone, sooner or later, will open.
Mixture. Two worlds meet — and a third one emerges. African rhythms meeting European harmony gave us jazz, blues, rock. The Caribbean meeting America gave us reggaeton. Of all the forces, this may be the most powerful.
Youth. A teenager searches for something that belongs to them and not to their parents. Music is the quickest way to say: “I’m not like you.”
The margins. The new almost always comes from below. From poor neighbourhoods, from ghettos, from the provinces. Those who have enough rarely feel an urgent need to change anything.
The scene. You need a community. People who listen to one another, argue, imitate, distort, rebuild. Without a scene, a style remains the private eccentricity of a single person.
And this is where it all comes down to one thing.
Music changes not because someone has invented a new chord. It changes because the human being has changed — the way they live, the people they identify with, what they fear, what they desire.
In the tribe, music is ritual. It does not change because the world will be the same tomorrow as it is today.
In the Middle Ages, music is truth. It does not change because truth is one.
Today, music is choice. It changes because choice is unlimited.
And if you are an artist, you are not really working with sound. You are working with the time in which your listener lives.
You either give them something they can recognize, or you give them something new.
Both are about them, not you.
Taste is not what a person chooses.
Taste is what a person becomes.
And now — a small prediction that may come true, or may not.
There are two forces at work.
One pulls forward: faster, stranger, louder, farther.
The other pulls backward: enough, we’re tired, give us back the way things were.
That is precisely why retro, nostalgia, analogue sound, folk and simplicity are so popular today.
Perhaps we are moving toward a new kind of stasis — not a tribal one, but a global one.
A world with so many styles that nobody has time to keep track of them all, where people simply choose their own and live inside it.
Just like a tribe.
Only now the tribe is based on interests, not blood.
And then the old man from the first chapter will no longer seem naïve.
Because we will have become that tribe ourselves.
Only with the internet and without spears.
So what do we have?
A tribe that sings the same song for a thousand years is not stagnant. It is perfection that has been reached and accepted.
The Middle Ages, singing the same song for a thousand years, are not impoverished. They are a world of order in which the new had no particular meaning.
Our world, changing styles as often as it likes, is not necessarily progress.
It is an environment in which the new pays.
The difference is not talent, nor imagination.
The difference is what a person needs music for:
ritual,
truth,
or choice.
Taste is not what a person chooses.
Taste is what a person becomes.
And music is merely a mirror.
And, like every mirror, it shows not simply what is there, but what we want to see.
The End. And if it isn’t the end, then to be continued — because the history of music never ends as long as there is someone left to listen.